Boer War Battlefields Talana Hill Magersfontein

Anglo-Boer War Page 28

Great Anglo-Boer War Battles 1

Battlefield Basics: The Anglo-Boer War started in Oct. 1899, with the same traditional, set-piece, infantry battles which European armies had been fighting for centuries. One group held ground that the others charged in "en masse," on foot, to take over. But the British were slow to discover that this style of warfare, which they had carried out successfully for so many years, demanded drastic changes. The Boers were using powerful modern Mauser clip-loading rifles that mowed down charging British infantrymen long before they got close enough to even see a Boer. Then, at the last possible moment, in a most unsporting manner, the Boers simply mounted horses and rode to safety, while the rest of the British Tommies - those who had not already been shot - on foot, could only watch and fume.

Set-piece battles (Talana, Elandslaagte, Enslin, Belmont, Colenso, Magersfontein, Spion Kop, Paardeberg), were early in the war. By June, 1900 the Boers refused to be drawn into them anymore and spent the last two years of the war launching unpredictable attacks on tunnels, bridges, towns, forts, and smaller British columns, both terrorizing the British and leaving their armies reeling and permanently off-balance. Boer guerilla tactics were so successful that at the end of the war some 450,000 British soldiers failed to capture the 12,000 Bitter Ender Boers who still remained fighting.


Henry Burr (1885-1941): "Break the News to Mother" 1918

You are listening to an original recording from the early 1900s featuring one of Canada's very first recording artists, Henry Burr, singing "Just Break the News to Mother," a song sung poignantly at home, and with bravado, in camps near the battlefront. Henry Burr from New Brunswick, started recording in 1902 while in his teens, and, with some 12,000 recordings to his credit, was the most prolific recording artist of his generation. "Just Break" was written by Chas. K. Harris, the first man to write a million selling song (After the Ball in 1892). This song, first written in 1891 for a dying fireman, was a flop but took off as a colossal hit during the Spanish American War in 1898, after he rewrote it featuring a soldier. (Lest you think the lyrics far-fetched, Lord Roberts of Kandahar, won his Victoria Cross exactly in this way while a young officer during the Indian Mutiny. But he survived.)

(You can hear these earliest Canadian recordings on our program's sound track. Details on our Music Page)


Talana Hill, Natal: Oct. 20, 1899

The First Battle: The opening shots of the Anglo-Boer War were fired across this meadow (right), when, on the morning of Oct. 20, 1899, the British camp in the field, awoke to see Boers on top of Talana Hill. The Boer guns fired on the camp below.

British General Penn-Symons (below right), ordered his men to "Take that hill boys." The huge Bacon lithograph (below) - though a fanciful recreation of the scene (right) - correctly shows the closely bunched British soldiers as they attacked up the hill, on a broad front which swept through the Smith Farm on the far right. A withering Boer Mauser fire cut them down by the scores.

A Heroic General: In the best tradition of British army officers, General Penn-Symons new rode on to the bullet-swept battlefield to re-energize the stalled attack.

(below) Pam McFadden, historian & curator of the Talana Hill Anglo-Boer War Museum, at Dundee, Natal, explains how Penn-Symons rode up to rally his men, dismounted at this wall (below), "Right in front of me. Right here, because it was too high for his horse to step over, and in doing so he presented a perfect target to the Boers on top of Talana Hill. He was mortally wounded."

Pam, standing in front of the cairn set up on the spot where Penn-Symons was shot, notes his last words to his men, "Don't mind me boys. I'll be out again tomorrow. The sad thing was he did not come out tomorrow but died of his wounds."

Penn-Symons' heroism energized his men, who charged the hill and swept the Boer off it. Penn-Symons' death received pride of place in the Bacon print (above and below). He lies alone now (right), in a corner of the Dundee churchyard (foreground).

Talana Hill - Oct. 20, 1899
A Glorious Victory: The troubles for the British were not over. When they reached the top of Talana Hill, many Tommies were killed by their own artillery fire (above), which could not distinguish between Briton and Boer at such long distances since everyone now wore khaki coloured clothing. The Bacon print correctly shows the distances that caused the problem, though not the correct colours for the uniforms.

The British cavalry unit, sent to cut off the fleeing Boers, was itself captured and sent as prisoners of war to Pretoria. The following day, Penn-Symons' successor abandoned not only Talana Hill, but the town of Dundee, fleeing in panic back to Ladysmith, leaving the British camp, the wounded, and the dying Penn-Symons, to the mercy of the Boers. The Boers reoccupied Talana Hill and were to stay in Dundee for many months to come.

Boer General Piet Joubert, sent Penn-Symons' personal effects and his condolences, to the General's widow in England. The Last of the Gentleman's Wars had begun.

Six months later, Lady Penn-Symons remarried, after an ungentlemanly short mourning period.

Magersfontein, OFS: Dec. 11, 1899

In the opening weeks of the war, the British army of Lord Methuen moved north, to capture General Cronje's troops which he supposed were entrenched on the Magersfontein Hills (right).

After one of the biggest artillery barrages in history, upon the hills, General Wauchope (below), led his Highland Brigade on a surprise night march to round up the supposedly destroyed and demoralized Boers.

Instead, the Boers were in trenches a distance in front of the hills, and cut down the surprised Highlanders, still marching packed together like sardines. Scores were buried around this memorial (right).

Historian John Goldi (below left) stands on the spot where the leading columns of Highlanders were cut down and General Wauchope (below) was fatally shot. It was one of the most disastrous defeats ever suffered by a British army.

Magersfontein - Dec. 11, 1899
Memories of Magersfontein: Memories from the Boer trenches: glass shards from drinking bottles, a shrapnel ball from Lord Methuen's bombardment of Dec. 10, 1899, and a spent Boer Martini-Henry shell (with a vintage cartridge for comparison.) The bullet from this shell probably ended the life of a British Highlander like General Wauchope (right).

A Small Twist of Fate Col. Otter's Royal Canadians, (Canada's First Contingent), were supposed to have been at Magersfontein, in the front ranks. In the old station house at Orange River Station (below), Otter (left) furiously tried to convince Maj. Larry Buchan his second-in-command (right), to have the men go.

"Good old Larry" as his men called him, adamantly refused, saying that the men were too green. (Only 10 men out of 1,000 had ever been under fire, and all had only been in South Africa for barely a week.)

All afternoon the loud argument of the officers bellowed out through this window (below right) as the men stood waiting behind the station house. 

Otter finally gave in, but called Buchan's behavior "mutinous". One can only guess at how many dozen young Canadian lives were saved as a result.


Colenso, Natal: Dec. 15, 1899

Prelude: The British South African commander-in-chief, Sir Redvers Buller VC (right), making his first attempt to relieve Ladysmith - which was surrounded by the Boers - decided to force a crossing over Tugela River at Colenso, then push through the line of hills held by the Boers on the north bank, to open the way to the town beyond.

British Tactics: Buller opted for an infantry assault over the road bridge in the town - which, inexplicably, the Boers had neglected to blow up - to get his army quickly to the north bank of the Tugela.

Boer Tactics: Opposing Buller was Louis Botha, a 37 year old farmer turned general, in his first command. It was he who had left the road bridge standing, to entice the British to cross there. He forbade his men from firing until enough of the British had crossed so that he could crush them between his trenches and the Tugela River at their backs. It would be a massacre of cataclysmic proportions. Holding back the Boer fire at all costs - so not to scare off the British - was the keystone of Louis Botha's battle plan.

Disaster #1 - Hart's Loop: Buller ordered General Fitzroy Hart (below left), to cross the Tugela River west of the village of Colenso, in parallel with the assault over the bridge. But Hart made a classic military blunder by ordering his men to march into a loop of the Tugela River on their way towards a ford/drift. Hart's Loop (below), is outlined by a row of trees in the middle distance.

Hundreds of Hart's men were massacred in the loop by a withering Boer crossfire coming at them from three sides. He had to withdraw back towards the left after suffering horrendous casualties.
Bugler Dunne: A British hero, salvaged from the disaster, was young Bugler Dunne, who was one of the few to reach the river (at the tip of the trees above), but dropped his bugle in the Tugela when his arm was shot while blowing the charge. As men around him fell or drowned in the river, the wounded youngster had to be prevented from going back to look for his bugle.

He survived to receive the replacement silver bugle (left) from Queen Victoria herself.

Disaster #2 - The Guns of Colonel Long: Buller had ordered Col. C.J. Long (left), and his 12 gun artillery unit, to advance with the infantry and give them covering fire. But Buller warned Long, not to get too far ahead of his infantry protection, or too close to the Boers.

But Long disobeyed. He believed that guns should be pushed right into the face of the enemy and destroy them at close range. This had been the traditional way artillery had been used for hundreds of years. The impetuous Long galloped his guns far ahead of the infantry, and to within only 300 yards of the river.

(below) Historian John Goldi, standing beside one of the stone blocks used to mark where each of Long's guns were parked on the day of the battle, points to where Boer sharpshooters watched incredulously as Long's gunners unlimbered their guns to take aim at them.

Louis Botha's Fateful Decision: Boer General Louis Botha had to make a quick decision. Fire on Long's guns and betray the Boer positions - and so ruin his plan to destroy the British on his side of the river - or allow Long to set up his guns and pulverize the Boer front line trenches at point blank range. Botha gave the signal to fire.

Within minutes a fire storm of Boer Mauser bullets, made the area around the stone blocks (right), a killing field as most of the 72 artillery horses were shot down and most of the gunners were killed or wounded. Long's guns fell silent and were abandoned by the survivors who cowered in the bush covered gully behind the blocks.

General Buller ordered that the guns be rescued.

Among the men who volunteered to return into the withering field of fire to rescue the guns was Freddy Roberts (above left). He was among several men who came gallopping up the valley pointed out by historian John Goldi (left) to the two guns that stood where these two stone blocks are today. Amid a hail of Boer Mauser fire they managed to hook up the two guns that stood here (German litho above) and gallop back down the valley to the safety of the British lines.

But Freddy fell, mortally wounded, near the bright speck in front of the bushes in the top picture.

So many men and horses where shot down that Buller called off all further rescue attempts. 10 British guns were abandoned to the Boers.

Seven Victoria Crosses were awarded - including one to Freddy - for the desperate acts of valour that took place on the small piece of ground around the two stone blocks (above).

Lord Roberts, Freddy's 67 year old father, learned on the morning of Dec. 16, that he would get his fondest wish - command of the army in South Africa to replace the hapless Buller. In the afternoon he received word that his only son had been killed at Colenso. They were the first father and son to each be awarded a VC.

A VC family tragedy would be repeated. One of the other VC's at Colenso would have a son who followed him into World War I and be killed in a heroic fight for which he would win a VC like his father had before him.

Hero or Villain? the Timeless Question of Colonel Long: To the British Col. Long has always been the villain of Colenso. He had failed to cover the infantry attack. And, at a time when losing one gun to the enemy was the absolute worst shame that could befall an army, Long had lost 10 to the Boers.

But Boer General Louis Botha disagreed strongly. He always maintained that Col. Long's daring charge right up to the Boer front lines - where he threatened to destroy their trenches with a devastating artillery barrage - forced Botha's hand to fire prematurely to protect the lives of his men. Botha believed, that, had Long advanced slowly with the infantry, as Buller had ordered him to, the British army would have fallen into Botha's trap, crossed the road bridge in good order - unbothered by Boers who were holding their fire - until thousands of Tommies were massed at the foot of the Tugela Heights. Then, with a mighty crash of thousands of Mausers and dozens of machine guns, the Boers would have massacred thousands of British soldiers in only minutes. The panic-stricken men not shot would have drowned trying to swim the Tugela to get away from the battlefield.

Louis Botha and the Boers always maintained that Col. Long's heroics had saved thousands of British lives that day at Colenso.


c Goldi Productions Ltd. 1996 & 2000